Category: Asset 8News & Views

Orphans cry

February 23, 2011

By Staff Reporter

By Ray O’Hanlon

They are often to be found on posters advertising concerts, but the four members of the band The Screaming Orphans could also be the poster children for the U.S. immigration system’s near blanket ban on visas for the Irish.

The Orphans, all members of the Diver family from Donegal, spend most of their working year in the United States, or playing on cruise ships sailing from U.S. ports. And they pay their taxes to Uncle Sam.

But while they are allowed work in the country, the all-girl foursome is required to apply for fresh working visas every year.

And this despite the fact that their mother is a U.S. citizen, and their father is a veteran who served honorably in the U.S. Army.

The Orphans, Joan, Angela, Gráinne and Marie Therese, occupy a kind of gray zone resulting from the return of a citizen parent to Ireland, and the fact that their citizen mother, Catherine, gave birth to her four girls an ocean away from her own birthplace in Elizabeth, New Jersey.

Never miss an issue of The Irish Echo

Subscribe to one of our great value packages.

“She was brought back by our granny and granddad and just stayed on,” said Grainne Diver in an interview.

In theory, Catherine could run for U.S. president. But she can’t pass on her citizenship to her daughters from her domicile in Ireland.

Their father, John Diver, has also found himself in a most unusual situation with regard to his status in the eyes of the U.S. government.

John Diver served in the U.S. Army in Germany back in the late 1950s. He was in the same army unit as Elvis Presley.

During his years of service, Diver earned himself a good conduct Medal, his Driver’s Badge and his Marksmanship Badge.

But on a day when he turned up at Dublin airport with a ticket for a flight to America, the U.S. immigration authorities took legal aim at his green card.

As Grainne explained it, her dad’s green card had expired and it was put to him that he could renounce it, secure a separate visa for that particular visit, or skip the flight entirely and go before a judge to appeal for a renewal of the green card.

With the Divers expected for an important event in New York, John felt compelled to renounce the green card and make the journey with the non-residency visa.

By doing so, he found myself in a category not unlike that of his daughters.

As it currently works, the Orphans must apply every year for a renewable P1 working visa. Already having a P1 is no guarantee of a renewal so the band lives and works from year to year in more ways than one.

They have outlined their hopes for a more secure visa situation in letters to Senators Chuck Schumer and John McCain but, so far at least, they have to keep applying to their annual visas.

“Every year they have to go to Dublin to get P1 visas. This is time consuming and costly for them and causes problems in setting up their schedule, which depended on when their P1 visas are issued,” said friend and supporter Eugene Hart, who lives in Omaha, Nebraska.

“I believe if anyone should get green cards it should be the daughters of a U.S. citizen and a veteran of the U.S. Army,” Hart said.

Other Articles You Might Like

Sign up to our Daily Newsletter

Click to access the login or register cheese